💭 ShopSavvy TLDR Reviews

Expertly researched reviews about products you're interested in, condensed down to a score, pros/cons and a bottom line.

Explore Content

More to Explore

TLDR Review: "Rogue One 4K UHD"

Item: "Rogue One 4K UHD"
Author: ShopSavvy

By ShopSavvy Team

Published: December 9th, 2024

Pros

•The 4K picture quality is excellent, offering an immersive visual experience.
•Surround sound in a home theater setup provides very good audio quality.
•The story effectively links Episodes III and IV, making it essential viewing for hardcore Star Wars fans.
•Offers a narrative that is both exciting and engaging, providing depth despite a known outcome.
•Stands out among prequels by enhancing the overall Star Wars narrative.
•Features relatable characters and strong performances, adding freshness to the viewing experience.
•Successfully balances darker themes with moments of humor, mainly through a droid character.
•Evokes nostalgia, particularly through the recreation of iconic characters like Peter Cushing's.
•Provides insights into the Star Wars universe, addressing significant plot holes.
•Highly recommended as a unique and emotional narrative within the franchise.

Cons

•Skipping and audio/video mismatches reported within the first DVD, despite exchanges.
•Disk freezing and skipping are significant issues reported by users.
•Some fans found the character development lacking, particularly for Saw Gerrera.
•SO, the new droid, was poorly received by some, who described it as unlikable.
•Limited screen time and unsatisfactory voice performance of CGI characters like Tarkin and Leia.
•Disappointment with the minimal role of Vader and his voice quality.
•Some visual effects, especially in the final battle scenes, fell short of Star Wars standards.
•Criticisms include plot contradictions, such as visibility of the Death Star to the rebel fleet.
•The film's darker tone and limited comedic moments didn't meet the typical series expectations.

Bottom Line

"SW ROGUE ONE US/EC/UD1/BD2/UD [4K UHD]" is a must-watch for Star Wars fans, offering a darker, engaging narrative that bridges significant gaps between Episodes III and IV. Its excellent picture and audio quality enhance the experience, but beware of potential issues with disk playback. While it excels in some areas, fans have noted shortcomings in character development and effects. If you're considering this product, prepare for a unique, albeit imperfect, addition to the Star Wars saga.

Lowest at Amazon

$44.44 at Amazon

Lowest at any Popular Retailer

$38.99 at Barnes & Noble